With season two of You fresh in our minds, Penn Badgley already confirmed that a third season is “unofficially” planned.

Former Gossip Girl and current You star, Penn Badgley sat down with Entertainment Tonight to discuss all things You, and had a major oops moment.

Penn touched briefly on what happened in the second season. Just as he began to contemplate what might happen next, saying, “Dare I say, I think in the third season,” he stopped, catching himself. Rolling his eyes, he said, “Oh, god.” Then said “I’m not the person that can say anything official.”

So there we have it, a third season of You is “unofficially” coming to Netflix.